Iklan

Pertanyaan

Questions 66-67 are based on the following passage.


    It has recently been discovered that many attributions of paintings to the seventeenth-century Dutch artist Rembrandt may be false. The contested paintings are not minor works, whose removal from the Rembrandt corpus would leave it relatively unaffected: they are at its very center. In her recent book, Svetlana Alpers uses these cases of disputed attribution as a point of departure for her provocative discussion of the radical distinctiveness of Rembrandt's approach to painting.

    Alpers argues that Rembrandt exercised an unprecedentedly firm control over his art, his students, and the distribution of his works. Despite Gary Schwartz's brilliant documentation of Rembrandt's complicated relations with a wide circle of patrons, Alpers takes the view that Rembrandt refused to submit to the prevailing patronage system. He preferred, she claims, to sell his works on the open market and to play the entrepreneur. At a time when Dutch artists were organizing into professional brotherhoods and academies, Rembrandt stood apart. In fact, Alpers portrait of Rembrandt shows virtually every aspect of his art pervaded by economic motives. Indeed, so complete was Rembrandt's involvement with the market, she argues, that he even presented himself as commodity, viewing his studio's products as extensions of himself, sent out into the world to earn money. Alpers asserts that Rembrandt's enterprise is found not just in his paintings, but in his refusal to limit his enterprise to those paintings he actually painted. He marketed Rembrandt.

    Although there may be some truth in the view that Rembrandt was an entrepreneur who made some aesthetic decisions on the basis of what he knew the market wanted, Alpers' emphasis on economic factors sacrifices discussions of the aesthetic qualities that make Rembrandt's work unique. For example, Alpers asserts that Rembrandt deliberately left his works unfinished so as to get more money for their revision and completion. She implies that Rembrandt actually wished the Council of Amsterdam to refuse the great Claudius Civilis, which they had commissioned for their new town hall, and she argues that he must have calculated that he would be able to get more money by retouching the painting. Certainly the picture is painted with very broad strokes but there is no evidence that it was deliberately left unfinished. The fact is that the look of a work like Claudius Civilis must also be understood as the consequence of Rembrandt's powerful and profound meditations on painting itself. Alpers makes no mention of the pictorial dialectic that can be discerned between, say, the lessons Rembrand absorbed from the Haarlem school of paintings and the styles of his native Leiden. The trouble is that while Rembrandt's artistic enterprise may indeed not be reducible to the works he himself painted, it is not reducible to marketing practices either.

67.According to the passage, Alpers and Schwartz disagree about which one of the following?

67. According to the passage, Alpers and Schwartz disagree about which one of the following?

  1. The degree of control Rembrandt exercised over the production of his art.

  2. The role that Rembrandt played in organizing professional brotherhoods and academies.

  3. The kinds of relationships Rembrandt had with his students.

  4. The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system.

  5. The role ofthe patronage system in seventeenthcentury Holland.

Ikuti Tryout SNBT & Menangkan E-Wallet 100rb

Habis dalam

02

:

11

:

27

:

52

Klaim

Iklan

D. Putri

Master Teacher

Mahasiswa/Alumni Universitas Negeri Yogyakarta

Jawaban terverifikasi

Jawaban

jawaban yang tepat untuk soal tersebut adalah D. The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system

jawaban yang tepat untuk soal tersebut adalah D. The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system

Pembahasan

Jawaban dari soal tersebut adalah D.The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system. Soal tersebut meminta untuk menentukan pendapat ketidak setujuan Alpers dan Schwartz sesuai dengan teks. Terjemahan dari soal adalah "Menurut teks tersebut, Alpers dan Schwartz tidak setuju pada bagian mana dari kalimat berikut ini?" Pada paragraf kedua, terdapat kalimat " Despite Gary Schwartz's brilliant documentation of Rembrandt's complicated relations with a wide circle of patrons, Alpers takes the view that Rembrandt refused to submit to the prevailing patronage system. He preferred, she claims, to sell his works on the open market and to play the entrepreneur. " yang artinya "Terlepas dari dokumentasi brilian Gary Schwartz tentang hubungan rumit Rembrandt dengan lingkaran patron yang luas, Alpers berpandangan bahwa Rembrandt menolak untuk tunduk pada sistem patronase yang berlaku. Dia lebih suka, katanya, untuk menjual karyanya di pasar terbuka dan bermain sebagai pengusaha." Berdasarkan penjelasan tersebut, dapat diketahui jika Swartz memiliki pendapat jika Rembrandt lebih memilih pasar bebas karena hubungannya dengan lingkaran patron yang rumit, sedangkan Alpers berpendapat jika Rembrandt memilih pasar bebas untuk menjual karyanya. Dengan demikian, kalimat yang tepat adalah " The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system. " yang artinya "Tingkat keterlibatan Rembrandt dalam sistem patronase." Jadi, jawaban yang tepat untuk soal tersebut adalah D. The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system

Jawaban dari soal tersebut adalah D. The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system.

Soal tersebut meminta untuk menentukan pendapat ketidak setujuan Alpers dan Schwartz sesuai dengan teks. Terjemahan dari soal adalah "Menurut teks tersebut, Alpers dan Schwartz tidak setuju pada bagian mana dari kalimat berikut ini?"

Pada paragraf kedua, terdapat kalimat "Despite Gary Schwartz's brilliant documentation of Rembrandt's complicated relations with a wide circle of patrons, Alpers takes the view that Rembrandt refused to submit to the prevailing patronage system. He preferred, she claims, to sell his works on the open market and to play the entrepreneur." yang artinya "Terlepas dari dokumentasi brilian Gary Schwartz tentang hubungan rumit Rembrandt dengan lingkaran patron yang luas, Alpers berpandangan bahwa Rembrandt menolak untuk tunduk pada sistem patronase yang berlaku. Dia lebih suka, katanya, untuk menjual karyanya di pasar terbuka dan bermain sebagai pengusaha." 

Berdasarkan penjelasan tersebut, dapat diketahui jika Swartz memiliki pendapat jika Rembrandt lebih memilih pasar bebas karena hubungannya dengan lingkaran patron yang rumit, sedangkan Alpers berpendapat jika Rembrandt memilih pasar bebas untuk menjual karyanya. Dengan demikian, kalimat yang tepat adalah "The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system." yang artinya "Tingkat keterlibatan Rembrandt dalam sistem patronase."

Jadi, jawaban yang tepat untuk soal tersebut adalah D. The degree of Rembrandt's involvement in the patronage system

Perdalam pemahamanmu bersama Master Teacher
di sesi Live Teaching, GRATIS!

1

Iklan

Pertanyaan serupa

Which of the following is NOT mentioned about Montgomery Bus Boycott?

5

0.0

Jawaban terverifikasi

RUANGGURU HQ

Jl. Dr. Saharjo No.161, Manggarai Selatan, Tebet, Kota Jakarta Selatan, Daerah Khusus Ibukota Jakarta 12860

Coba GRATIS Aplikasi Roboguru

Coba GRATIS Aplikasi Ruangguru

Download di Google PlayDownload di AppstoreDownload di App Gallery

Produk Ruangguru

Hubungi Kami

Ruangguru WhatsApp

+62 815-7441-0000

Email info@ruangguru.com

[email protected]

Contact 02130930000

02130930000

Ikuti Kami

©2026 Ruangguru. All Rights Reserved PT. Ruang Raya Indonesia