Mother : Ta, have you had your breakfast?
Ita : N...

Question

Mother : Ta, have you had your breakfast? 
Ita : Not yet, mum. 
Father : What did your mother ask you, Ita? 
Ita : Oh, she wanted to know whether _____

a. I had my breakfast
b.  I had had my breakfast
c.  You had your breakfast
d.  I have had my breakfast
e.  You had had my breakfast

F. Anintya · Accepted Answer

Jawaban yang benar adalah (B) I had had my breakfast.

Soal ini meminta kita melengkapi kalimat dalam dialog dengan kalimat tak langsung.

Dialognya adalah:
Mother : Ta, have you had your breakfast? (Ta, apakah kamu sudah sarapan?)
Ita : Not yet, mum. (Belum, ma.)
Father : What did your mother ask you, Ita? (Apa yang ditanyakan ibu padamu, Ita?)
Ita : Oh, she wanted to know whether _____. (Oh, ia ingin tahu apakah _____).

Kalimat langsungnya adalah 'have you had your breakfast?'. 'You' pada kalimat tersebut merujuk pada Ita. Maka, apabila diubah dalam kalimat tak langsung yang dikatakan Ita, 'you' berubah menjadi 'I'.

Kalimat tersebut berpola Present Perfect (have/has + V3). Untuk diubah ke kalimat tak langsung, Tense tersebut diubah menjadi Past Perfect (had + V3).

Perhatikan pilihan jawabannya:
A. I (S) + had (V2) + my breakfast
B. I (S) + had + had (V3) + my breakfast
C. You (S) + had (V2) + your breakfast
D. I (S) + have + had (V3) + my breakfast
E. You (S) + had + had (V3) + my breakfast

Jawaban yang memiliki rumus yang sesuai dengan Past Perfect adalah jawaban B dengan Pronoun yang diubah menjadi 'I'.

Kalimat lengkapnya menjadi 'Oh, she wanted to know whether I had had my breakfast. (Oh, ia ingin tahu apakah aku sudah sarapan).
 
Jadi, jawaban yang tepat adalah (B) I had had my breakfast.

Mother : Ta, have you had your breakfast? Ita : Not yet, mum. Father : What did your mother ask you, Ita? Ita : Oh, she wanted to know whether _____ a. I had my breakfast b. I had had my breakfast c. You had your breakfast d. I have had my breakfast e. You had had my breakfast

Mau pemahaman lebih dalam untuk soal ini?

Pertanyaan serupa