Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus

This boo...

Question

Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus 

This book is great as a way of understanding how our culture trains boys and girls to be different. We teach girls that they can cry when they are sad, talk about their feelings, and share experiences with each other. We teach boys that they need to ´buck up´ and be manly, to hide the tears, to face it like a man, to be the rock on which the females can rely. It is no surprise that these lessons affect adults, and affect how male and females relate (or fail to relate) to each other. 

In essence, a few core themes run through the book, being supported by various examples, and different wording that help make the points clear. 

First, men are goal-oriented and when they are stressed, “retreat to a cave” to consider what to do. They want to come to a solution on their own. To try to help them while they are in the “cave” is counter productive. 

Men want to be trusted and admired. They want to feel that the woman believes in them. To question a man is to show your doubt. The book recommends if a man is lost while driving, or forgets something while travelling, to just be quiet and accept it. It will show your trust in him to get there eventually or to solve the problem. I´m personally not sure if this is always wise advice. 

Women, on the other hand, are nurturing, expressive, feeling individuals who tend to use poetic license such as saying “you ALWAYS forget to do that chore” or “you NEVER listen to me”. The advice given to men is not to react to any of what women say literally. Most of what women want, according to the book, is just to be heard. Women don´t want solutions or answers. They want to feel that their feelings are being heard and understood ... they want to be held and be told “Yes, yes, I understand”. The book explains that men make the mistake of thinking women tell them things in order for the men to *fi x* those things. Instead, the women tell them things in order to share their feelings, but aren´t seeking actual resolutions. 

While I agree that women are trained to share feelings and to sometimes be overly emotional, to tell a man that women never want resolutions, and always exaggerate, is not treating a woman as a logical human being perfectly capable of wanting answers. 

There is definitely a lot of helpful information in the book. It is good to understand that society trains men to “retreat” to consider problems, and that they consider interference during this time as “harassment” instead of “helpful”. It´s good to realize that women have emotional cycles and can sometimes be happy, and sometimes sad, and that nobody is always happy. This book definitely has interesting hints and tips, and interesting stories to share. It also has many generalizations that, for many individuals, simply do not apply.


1. How does our culture train boys and girls?

V. Valerie · Accepted Answer

Halo Mutia, kakak bantu jawab ya...

Jawabannya adalah 'Our culture teaches girls that they can cry when they are sad, talk about their feelings, and share experiences with each other. They teach boys that they need to ´buck up´ and be manly, to hide the tears, to face it like a man, to be the rock on which the females can rely.'

Soal menanyakan bagaimana budaya kita melatih anak laki-laki dan perempuan.

Pada paragraf pertama tertulis "This book is great as a way of understanding how our culture trains boys and girls to be different. We teach girls that they can cry when they are sad, talk about their feelings, and share experiences with each other. We teach boys that they need to ´buck up´ and be manly, to hide the tears, to face it like a man, to be the rock on which the females can rely."

Terjemahannya:
"Buku ini sangat bagus sebagai cara untuk memahami bagaimana budaya kita melatih anak laki-laki dan perempuan untuk menjadi berbeda. Kami mengajari para perempuan bahwa mereka dapat menangis ketika mereka sedih, membicarakan perasaan mereka, dan berbagi pengalaman satu sama lain. Kami mengajari anak laki-laki bahwa mereka perlu 'bersabar' dan menjadi jantan, menyembunyikan air mata, menghadapinya seperti laki-laki, menjadi batu karang yang dapat diandalkan perempuan."

Berdasarkan informasi tersebut dapat diketahui bahwa budaya kita mengajarkan para perempuan bahwa mereka dapat menangis ketika mereka sedih, membicarakan perasaan mereka, dan berbagi pengalaman satu sama lain. Kita mengajari anak laki-laki bahwa mereka perlu 'bersabar' dan menjadi jantan, menyembunyikan air mata, menghadapinya seperti laki-laki, menjadi batu karang yang dapat diandalkan perempuan.

Jadi, jawabannya adalah 'Our culture teaches girls that they can cry when they are sad, talk about their feelings, and share experiences with each other. They teach boys that they need to ´buck up´ and be manly, to hide the tears, to face it like a man, to be the rock on which the females can rely.'

Semoga membantu, selamat belajar!

Mau pemahaman lebih dalam untuk soal ini?

Pertanyaan serupa